Mince Pie Leaderboards

To save you having to root through every blog post each year, here’s the mince pies I’ve reviewed in handy leaderboards. Happy eating!

2020 Mince Pies

ManufacturerMince Pie NameScore
ASDAASDA Extra Special Luxury Sloe Gin Mince Pie Review 20209
Co-opCo-op Old Fashioned Clementine Flavour Buttercream Mince Pie Review 20208
MorrisonsMorrisons ‘The Best’ All Butter Deep Filled Mince Pie Review 20208
LyonsLyon’s Cakes Mince Pie Review 20208
Co-opCo-op Mince Pie Review 20208
Co-opCo-op Puff Pastry Mince Pies7.5
AldiAldi Holly Lane Deep Filled Mince Pie Review 20207
MorrisonsMorrisons ‘The Best’ Free From Maple Crumble Mince Pie Review 20205
Co-opCo-op Shortcrust Mince Pie Review 20205
TescoTesco Butter Enriched Pastry Mince Pie Review4
Mr KiplingMr Kipling Deep Filled Mince Pie Review 20203
MorrisonsMorrisons ‘The Best’ Deep Filled All Butter Mince Pie Review 20202

2019 Mince Pies

ManufacturerMince Pie NameScore
ASDAASDA Extra Special Crumble Mince Pie Review9
Sainsbury'sSainsbury’s Deep Filled Mince Pie Review9
Co-opCo-op Irresistible Butter-Enriched Deep Filled Mince Pie Review9
ASDAExtra Special Deep Filled Mince Pie Review8.5
ASDAASDA Mince Pie Filled Cookie Review8.5
M&SMarks & Spencer Collection Mince Pie Review8
Mr KiplingMr Kipling Deep Filled Mince Pie Review7
TescoTesco Lattice Topped Mince Pie Review6.5
LidlAldi Specially Selected All Butter Classic Mince Pie Review6
Sainsbury'sSainsbury’s Free From (Gluten Free) Mince Pie Review
6
ALDIAldi Specially Selected All Butter Classic Mince Pie Review6
ASDAASDA Shallow Fill Bakery Mince Pie Review2
ASDAASDA Shallow Fill Bakery Mince Pie Review2
Co-opCo-op Mince Pie Review0

2018 Mince Pies

ManufacturerMince Pie NameScore
ASDAExtra Special Deep Filled Mince Pie (Review)10
LidlDeluxe Luxury Mince Pie (Review)9.5
Co-opIrresistible All Butter Pastry Deep Filled Mince Pie (Review)9
SainsburysMince Pie Flavour Cookies (Review)9
TescoFinest Deep Filled Mince Pie with Courvoisier Cognac (Review)8.5
LidlFavorina Mince Pie (Review)8
Joe&SephGourmet Mince Pie Popcorn (Review)8
SainsburysDeep Filled Mince Pie (Review)7.5
Co-opIrresistible Brandy Buttercream Mince Pie (Review)7.5
TescoLattice Topped Mince Pie (Review)7.5
Co-opAll Butter Pastry Luxury Mince Pie (Review)7
SainsburysTaste The Difference All Butter Mince Pie (Review)6.5
AldiSpecially Selected All Butter Classic Mince Pie (Review)6.5
AldiSpecially Selected Salted Caramel Mince Pie (Review)4

You're currently offline